Purchase Order Errors: When Identifying the Wrong Party Puts Contractual Rights at Risk

Before the first truck leaves your yard, check whose name is on the purchase order. On a busy construction project, the purchase order is often the document evidencing the parties’ contractual relationship. As the case below demonstrates, naming the wrong party, or leaving one out, is more than a housekeeping error. It can be fatal, leaving the parties that actually supplied the materials and services with no remedy and no payment.

In JCL Concrete Pumping Ltd v SEMA Railway Structures Inc, two related suppliers delivered materials and equipment, but the purchase order incorrectly identified the supplier as JCL Group Inc. As the purchase order was the only contractual document exchanged, the Court found that neither supplier had established a contract with SEMA, leaving both unpaid and without construction lien rights after trial.

When a Construction Purchase Order Names the Wrong Company

Metrolinx retained SEMA to rehabilitate a railway bridge. Two related suppliers, OTD and JCL Concrete, provided materials and equipment for the project.

SEMA’s representative, Jean-Philippe Poirier, was contacted by Santo Costabile, who acted for both suppliers. However, SEMA issued a single purchase order addressed to JCL Group Inc, a related entity, rather than OTD or JCL Concrete. Costabile accepted that purchase order on behalf of both suppliers without challenging the name.

When a payment dispute arose, OTD and JCL Concrete each preserved and perfected separate construction liens. The central question at trial was whether SEMA had two contracts, one with OTD and one with JCL Concrete, or whether it had one contract with JCL Group Inc.

How Courts Identify Contracting Parties in Construction Disputes

Contract formation is assessed objectively. Rather than relying on what a party privately intended, courts consider what a reasonable person would have understood from the parties’ words and conduct – the reasonable person standard.

In JCL, several factors supported the conclusion that SEMA was reasonably entitled to believe it was dealing with JCL Group Inc. Costabile’s email signature identified him as the manager of JCL Group Inc. Communications came from its email domain, and delivery tickets and trucks carried its name. However, the Court also acknowledged that Costabile used OTD and JCL Concrete letterhead to submit price lists that SEMA ultimately accepted.

Accordingly, despite both OTD and JCL having submitted price lists on their respective letterheads, which SEMA accepted, and having supplied the materials and services, the Court found that neither had established a contract with SEMA. The purchase order, together with the surrounding documentation, was sufficient for the Court to conclude that JCL Group Inc was technically the contracting party.

How Purchase Order Errors Can Affect Construction Lien Rights

Suppliers and subcontractors should not assume that delivering goods or services automatically secures their payment and lien rights.

In this case, the suppliers could not establish the contractual relationship necessary to support their liens, despite each having supplied services. Confusingly, both lien claimants withdrew their quantum meruit claims, which seek reasonable compensation for work performed or services provided, before trial, eliminating a potential alternative basis for recovery when their contractual arguments failed.

Beyond the quantum meruit argument, this decision demonstrates that details matter. No supplier or contractor should presume that a court will subordinate technical arguments to what in fact occurred on the project. The decision demonstrates how unclear contractual documentation, combined with decisions made during litigation, can leave businesses without an effective remedy for unpaid work.

Five Ways Contractors and Suppliers Can Protect Payment Rights

Construction businesses can reduce these risks by taking a few practical precautions:

  • Verify contracting parties. Confirm the correct legal names of all parties before supplying materials, equipment or services.
  • Enter into a valid contract. A short-form written agreement that correctly identifies the contracting parties and essential contractual terms can help protect the interests of everyone involved.
  • Correct purchase order errors. When a separate written agreement isn’t possible, ensure that all documentation clearly identifies the contracting parties. If a purchase order names the wrong company, request a written correction, ideally before accepting it or beginning work.
  • Keep documentation consistent. Ensure quotes, email signatures, delivery tickets and invoices accurately identify the business providing the goods or services, particularly when related companies share branding or personnel.
  • Consider alternative claims. Where contract formation is disputed, assess potential alternative payment claims, including quantum meruit, before narrowing the issues for trial.

These steps are particularly important for businesses operating through multiple related corporations, where inconsistent documentation can create confusion about which company is entering into the contract.

The Bottom Line

A simple naming error can become a costly payment dispute. JCL reinforces the importance of clear contractual documentation and consistent communications from the outset. Confirming who is contracting with whom before work begins can help protect payment rights and avoid litigation over an issue that could have been resolved at the start.


HOW WE CAN HELP

RAR Litigation advises contractors, subcontractors, suppliers and other construction industry participants on contractual disputes, payment claims and construction liens.

Our team assists clients with contract interpretation, lien enforcement and disputes arising from purchase orders and construction agreements. We help businesses identify contractual risks, protect their payment rights and resolve disputes when they arise.

Contact us for advice on protecting your contractual and financial interests.

Share
Date: